On this page
- 01Key takeaways
- 02Why score calls at all?
- 03What should you score?
- 04How many calls should you score?
- 05How do you turn scores into fixes?
- 06How is this different from the five-call test?
- 07Who should do the scoring?
- 08What does this look like in practice?
- 09Call scoring checklist
- 10Next step
- 11Sources and further reading
- 12Frequently asked questions
Key takeaways
A monthly call quality sample shows whether your answering service is handling calls the way you want. Pick about ten recorded calls, including a busy-hour call, an emergency and an awkward call, and score each out of five on greeting, questions, action, notes and tone. Share the scores and one fix with the provider each month.
- Sample about ten calls a month.
- Include busy-hour, emergency and awkward calls.
- Score greeting, questions, action, notes and tone.
- Share scores and one fix monthly.
Want a call scoring sheet for your service? Message us on WhatsApp.
Chat on WhatsApp →Why score calls at all?
Reports show speed and volume, not quality. Listening to calls tells you how callers are treated, whether the script works and whether receptionists follow your emergency rule. Scoring makes it consistent month to month.
What should you score?
Use five criteria, one point each.
- Greeting: business name, friendly and short.
- Questions: the right ones for the job type.
- Action: booked, transferred or callback set correctly.
- Notes: complete, accurate and on time.
- Tone: calm, clear and sounding like your business.
How many calls should you score?
About ten a month is enough for most trades businesses. Include a mix: busy hours, emergencies, out of hours and awkward calls, not just the easy ones.
Want help choosing the right calls to score? Message us on WhatsApp and we will discuss your requirements.
Chat on WhatsApp →How do you turn scores into fixes?
Look for the lowest criterion across the sample. Fix that in the script or through feedback. Next month, check it has improved. Keep a simple table of monthly scores so you can see trends and show the provider progress over time.
How is this different from the five-call test?
The five-call test checks a provider before you sign. Monthly scoring checks real calls after you start. Use the same five criteria so results are comparable.
Who should do the scoring?
Ideally the same person each month, so scores are consistent. That might be the owner or an office lead. If several people score, agree what a point means for each criterion first, using a couple of example calls.
What does this look like in practice?
A pattern we see: monthly scores show greetings and tone are strong, but questions score low on boiler calls. Adding make and model questions lifts the score and the first-visit fix rate.
Call scoring checklist
- Pick ten calls monthly.
- Include hard calls.
- Score five criteria.
- Find the lowest criterion.
- Fix it with the provider.
- Recheck next month.
Next step
Score ten calls from last month using the five criteria and send the provider one fix.
Message us on WhatsApp for a scoring sheet, or book a 30-minute consultation.
Chat on WhatsApp →Sources and further reading
- Lawful basis for processing personal data · Information Commissioner's Office
- Principle (d): Accuracy · Information Commissioner's Office
Frequently asked questions
How many answering service calls should I listen to?
About ten a month is usually enough for a trades business, chosen to include busy times, emergencies, out-of-hours and awkward calls. Listen to more in the first few months or after any script change. Consistent sampling matters more than the exact number.
What should I listen for in recorded calls?
The greeting, whether the right questions were asked, whether the right action was taken, whether the note matches the call and the tone used. Also listen for safety wording on emergency calls. Score each area the same way every month so you can see trends.
Should the answering service know I am scoring calls?
Yes. Tell the provider you review a monthly sample and share the scores and fixes with them. Most good providers welcome it, because it gives them clear feedback. Openness also makes it easier to agree changes and see whether they work.
Written by

Global Bridge Labs (GBL) is a UK–Sri Lanka partner for social media, websites and BPO. Everything here comes from client delivery, not theory.




