On this page
Key takeaways
This scorecard gives you 20 yes or no checks in four groups of five: coverage, capture, action and terms. Score one point per yes for each provider. A score of 16 or more is a strong fit, 12 to 15 means ask more questions before signing, and under 12 means keep looking. Use it alongside the GBL five-call test.
- 20 checks in four groups of five.
- 16 or more: a strong fit.
- 12 to 15: ask more questions first.
- Under 12: keep looking.
Want us to score your shortlist with you? Message us on WhatsApp.
Chat on WhatsApp →How do you use the scorecard?
Work through the 20 checks for each shortlisted provider, answering yes only when you have evidence, such as a written answer, a test call or a contract clause. Count the yes answers, compare totals and look at the lowest group, because that is where the risk sits.
What do the four groups check?
Coverage checks whether calls are answered when they arrive. Capture checks whether the right details are taken. Action checks whether calls become bookings, transfers or chased quotes. Terms check cost, contracts and data.
- Coverage: hours, speed, peaks, holidays.
- Capture: questions, notes, photos, recordings.
- Action: booking, transfers, emergencies, chasing.
- Terms: price, contract, number, data.
How should you read the score?
A high score means the provider is likely to answer your calls well and turn them into work. A middle score means gaps that questions or contract changes may close. A low score means the provider is unlikely to fit, whatever the price. A failed emergency check should rule a provider out on its own.
Want help scoring a provider? Message us on WhatsApp and we will discuss your requirements.
Chat on WhatsApp →When is the scorecard most useful?
When you have two or three providers with similar prices and want a fair way to choose, or when a cheap provider looks tempting and you want to check what you would give up.
What does this look like in practice?
A pattern we see: the cheapest provider scores 10 because it cannot book or transfer and has a long contract. A mid-priced provider scores 17 and wins on cost per booked job too.
The 20 checks
- Coverage: does it cover all the hours you need?
- Coverage: does it answer most calls within about 20 seconds?
- Coverage: can it show answer times for its busiest week?
- Coverage: does it cover bank holidays?
- Coverage: does it have a plan for weather surges?
- Capture: will it use your trade's questions?
- Capture: do notes arrive within five minutes?
- Capture: will it request photos?
- Capture: does it record calls with a clear retention period?
- Capture: did it capture all details on test calls?
- Action: can it book into your diary or job software?
- Action: can it transfer calls with a fallback?
- Action: did it follow your emergency wording exactly?
- Action: can it chase quotes?
- Action: does it send monthly reports?
- Terms: is the price at your volume in writing?
- Terms: is the first term three months or less?
- Terms: does your number stay yours?
- Terms: is there a processor contract?
- Terms: is cost per booked job below your profit per job?
Scorecard checklist
- Shortlist two or three providers.
- Gather evidence for each check.
- Score each provider.
- Compare totals.
- Check the lowest group.
- Rule out any emergency failure.
Next step
Print the 20 checks and score each shortlisted provider after your test calls.
Message us on WhatsApp for the scorecard as a sheet, or book a 30-minute consultation.
Chat on WhatsApp →Sources and further reading
- Contracts and liabilities between controllers and processors · Information Commissioner's Office
- Consumer Contracts (Information, Cancellation and Additional Charges) Regulations 2013 · legislation.gov.uk
- Gas Safe Register · Gas Safe Register
Frequently asked questions
What is the most important check on the answering service scorecard?
For trades, whether the provider followed your emergency wording exactly on a test call. Emergency handling protects customers and your reputation, and a failure there should rule a provider out whatever else it scores. After that, booking ability and cost per booked job usually matter most.
Can I use the scorecard for an AI answering service?
Yes. Most checks apply, especially speed, capture, emergency handling and data. Pay close attention to postcode accuracy, the route to a human and how recordings and transcripts are stored and used. Score it the same way and compare with human services on cost per booked job.
How long does it take to complete the scorecard?
Once you have run test calls and received written answers and contracts, scoring each provider takes about 20 to 30 minutes. Gaps in your evidence become useful questions for a final call with each provider before you decide, which often settles the choice.
Written by

Global Bridge Labs (GBL) is a UK–Sri Lanka partner for social media, websites and BPO. Everything here comes from client delivery, not theory.




