GLOBAL BRIDGE LABS
← All posts/Social Media Management

Agency premium worksheet: compare two proposals

Agency premium worksheet: compare two social media agency proposals line by line on hours, seniority, cost and the results needed to pay back.

By Dhanushka Pinto, Co-founder / DirectorPublished 3 min read
Agency comparison worksheet: key takeaways infographic by Global Bridge Labs
Key takeaways from this article. Share it with the link and credit Global Bridge Labs.
On this page

Key takeaways

This worksheet compares two agency proposals in six lines: monthly fee, monthly hours, senior hours, deliverables, yearly premium and the extra customers needed to cover it. Fill it in for both agencies and the cost of the premium becomes clear. If the cheaper agency matches the other on hours and seniority, the premium is mostly overhead.

  • Six lines compare two proposals.
  • Hours and seniority show what you buy.
  • The yearly premium puts the gap in pounds.
  • Extra customers needed shows if it can pay back.

Want us to fill in the worksheet with your proposals? Message us on WhatsApp.

Chat on WhatsApp →

What goes in the agency premium worksheet?

The worksheet has six lines for each agency: monthly fee, total monthly hours, senior hours, key deliverables, yearly cost and blended hourly rate. Then two comparison lines: the yearly premium of the dearer agency and the extra customers needed to cover it, using your customer value.

How do you fill it in?

Ask each agency for monthly hours by role and the deliverables included. Divide each fee by its hours for a blended rate. Multiply the monthly difference by twelve for the yearly premium. Divide the premium by the profit from one customer to get customers needed.

  • Fee and hours from each proposal.
  • Senior hours named separately.
  • Monthly difference times twelve.
  • Premium divided by profit per customer.

How do you read the result?

If the dearer agency offers notably more senior hours, production or relevant results, and the customers needed look achievable, the premium may be worth it. If hours and seniority are similar, the gap is overhead or reputation, and the cheaper agency is likely better value.

Want help interpreting your worksheet? Message us on WhatsApp and we will discuss your requirements.

Chat on WhatsApp →

When is the worksheet most revealing?

It is most revealing when proposals look similar at first glance but differ in price, because it shows exactly where the difference goes.

When do you need more than the worksheet?

You need more when proposals differ in strategy or approach, which numbers cannot capture. Use meetings, references and a scoring matrix alongside it.

What does this look like in practice?

A pattern we see: two proposals differ by £900 a month. The worksheet shows similar total hours, but one includes six senior hours against two. The premium now has a clear explanation to weigh.

Worksheet checklist

  • Get monthly hours by role.
  • List senior hours separately.
  • Work out blended hourly rates.
  • Calculate the yearly premium.
  • Divide by profit per customer.

Next step

Ask both agencies for hours by role this week, then fill in the six lines side by side.

Message us on WhatsApp for the worksheet template, or book a 30-minute consultation.

Chat on WhatsApp →

Sources and further reading

Frequently asked questions

What if an agency will not share its hours?

Some agencies sell outcomes or packages rather than hours. Ask at least for the roles involved, approximate time and deliverables. If an agency refuses any indication of time or people, it is hard to judge what the fee buys, which is worth weighing in your decision.

Should I use profit or revenue per customer?

Use profit, or at least gross margin, per customer. Revenue overstates what you can afford to spend, because it ignores the cost of delivering your product or service. Using profit gives a realistic number of extra customers needed to cover the agency premium.

Can the worksheet compare more than two agencies?

Yes. Add a column for each agency and compare each against the cheapest suitable option. The yearly premium and customers needed then show how much each extra pound buys. Keep the comparison to agencies quoting for the same scope, or the numbers mislead.

Written by

Dhanushka Pinto
Dhanushka Pinto
Co-founder / Director

Global Bridge Labs (GBL) is a UK–Sri Lanka partner for social media, websites and BPO. Everything here comes from client delivery, not theory.

Share this article

Reading is good.
Fixing is better.

30 minutes with our team and you'll leave knowing which of the three problems to fix first.

Get a Free Quote →
Keep reading