On this page
- 01Key takeaways
- 02How do you use the award-winning agency checklist?
- 03What do the four groups check?
- 04How should you read the score?
- 05When is the checklist most useful?
- 06When should you look beyond the score?
- 07What does this look like in practice?
- 08The 20 checks
- 09Next step
- 10Sources and further reading
- 11Frequently asked questions
Key takeaways
This checklist gives you 20 yes or no checks, in four groups of five: the award, the team, the fit and the value. Score one point per yes. 16 or more: the premium is likely justified. 12 to 15: ask more questions before signing. Under 12: compare with agencies that fit you better.
- 20 checks in four groups of five.
- 16 or more yes answers: the premium is likely justified.
- 12 to 15: ask more questions first.
- Under 12: compare with better-fitting agencies.
Want us to run this checklist with you? Message us on WhatsApp.
Chat on WhatsApp →How do you use the award-winning agency checklist?
Work through the 20 checks for each agency you are considering, answering yes only when you have evidence. Count the yes answers. Compare totals across agencies, then look at which group scored lowest, because that is where the risk sits. The checklist builds on the GBL award relevance test.
What do the four groups check?
The award group checks what was judged and whether it is current. The team group checks who did the work and who will serve you. The fit group checks client size, sector and budget. The value group checks hours, results and terms.
- Award: what, when and how judged.
- Team: who won it and who serves you.
- Fit: size, sector and budget.
- Value: hours, results and terms.
How should you read the score?
A high score means the award is relevant and the premium is likely to reach your account. A middle score means gaps you can often close with questions. A low score means the award says little about your account, so compare on other evidence.
Want help scoring agencies on your shortlist? Message us on WhatsApp and we will discuss your requirements.
Chat on WhatsApp →When is the checklist most useful?
It is most useful when one agency's awards are pulling you towards a higher fee and you want a fair way to test whether they matter for your account.
When should you look beyond the score?
Look beyond the score when one check is critical for you, such as sector rules, or when references reveal something the checklist does not cover.
What does this look like in practice?
A pattern we see: an agency with an impressive award scores 11 because the winning team has left and the client sizes differ. A less famous agency scores 17 and wins the account.
The 20 checks
- Award: was it judged on business results?
- Award: was it won in the last three years?
- Award: was it a win, not only a shortlisting?
- Award: can you verify it on the scheme's site?
- Award: was the agency the lead on the work?
- Team: do you know who did the winning work?
- Team: will any of them work on your account?
- Team: have you met your delivery team?
- Team: are senior hours written into the proposal?
- Team: has your proposed team been there a year or more?
- Fit: was the winning work for a business like yours?
- Fit: is your budget within its normal client range?
- Fit: does it know your sector's rules?
- Fit: have you seen a typical month of live client work?
- Fit: did a similar client give a good reference?
- Value: do you know the monthly hours your fee buys?
- Value: have you priced the yearly premium?
- Value: could extra results plausibly cover it?
- Value: is the first term six months or less?
- Value: do you own all accounts and content?
Next step
Print the 20 checks and score each shortlisted agency after your final meetings.
Message us on WhatsApp for the checklist as a scoresheet, or book a 30-minute consultation.
Chat on WhatsApp →Sources and further reading
- IPA Effectiveness Awards · IPA
- Substantiation: advice on backing up marketing claims · ASA and CAP
- Find and update company information · Companies House
Frequently asked questions
What is the most important check for an award-winning agency?
The most important check is usually whether the people who won the award will work on your account. An award reflects specific people's skill with a specific client. If they will not be involved, the award says much less about the service you will receive for the higher fee.
Can a non-award-winning agency use this checklist?
Yes. Skip the award group and score the other 15 checks out of 15, then compare proportionally. Many agencies without awards score highly on team, fit and value, which are the areas that most affect your day-to-day results and the return on your fee.
How long does the checklist take to complete?
Most checks can be answered from proposals, meetings, references and a short online search, so expect around 30 to 60 minutes per agency once you have that information. Gaps in your answers become useful questions for your final meetings with each agency.
Written by

Global Bridge Labs (GBL) is a UK–Sri Lanka partner for social media, websites and BPO. Everything here comes from client delivery, not theory.




