On this page
- 01Key takeaways
- 02What mistakes do buyers make when choosing on awards?
- 03What do these mistakes cost?
- 04How do you avoid each mistake?
- 05When is relying on awards reasonable?
- 06When do award mistakes matter most?
- 07What does this look like in practice?
- 08Award mistakes checklist
- 09Next step
- 10Sources and further reading
- 11Frequently asked questions
Key takeaways
The biggest mistakes when choosing an agency on awards are treating any award as proof of results, ignoring who won it, not checking if it relates to your needs, overlooking agencies that do not enter awards and paying a premium without pricing it. Each is avoidable with a few questions before signing.
- Treating any award as proof of results.
- Ignoring who did the winning work.
- Not matching the award to your needs.
- Paying a premium without pricing it.
Want to avoid award-driven agency mistakes? Message us on WhatsApp.
Chat on WhatsApp →What mistakes do buyers make when choosing on awards?
Common mistakes include treating creative awards as proof of results, not asking who did the winning work, ignoring how old the award is, not checking the agency's role, counting shortlistings as wins, overlooking agencies that never enter awards, ignoring client size fit and not pricing the premium.
What do these mistakes cost?
They can cost thousands of pounds a year in unnecessary premiums, months of poor results with a junior team or an agency built for different clients, and the expense of switching again. The cost is highest for small businesses where the fee is a large share of the budget.
- Unnecessary yearly premiums.
- Months of weak results.
- Switching costs later.
How do you avoid each mistake?
Ask what was judged, who did the work, when, for whom and what the agency's role was. Check the scheme's results. Include an agency without awards in your comparison. Price the premium per year and divide by profit per customer.
Want a second opinion before you sign? Message us on WhatsApp and we will discuss your requirements.
Chat on WhatsApp →When is relying on awards reasonable?
It is reasonable when the award was for effectiveness in a market like yours, the winning team will serve you and the premium is affordable relative to likely results.
When do award mistakes matter most?
They matter most for small budgets, long contracts and businesses with specific needs, such as regulated sectors, that the award-winning work did not address.
What does this look like in practice?
A pattern we see: a buyer chooses an agency for a well-known award, then discovers the award was for production work by a partner company. Asking about the agency's role would have revealed it.
Award mistakes checklist
- Ask what the award judged.
- Ask who did the work.
- Check the award's age.
- Confirm the agency's role.
- Price the premium per year.
Next step
For the award that most influences you, ask the five questions: what, who, when, for whom and what role.
Message us on WhatsApp for an agency check, or book a 30-minute consultation.
Chat on WhatsApp →Sources and further reading
Frequently asked questions
What is the biggest mistake when choosing an award-winning agency?
The biggest mistake is assuming the award predicts your results without checking who did the work, what was judged and whether it resembles your needs. Awards reflect specific people, budgets and clients. Without those links to your account, the award may say little about the service you will receive.
Should I avoid agencies that have no awards?
No. Many capable agencies never enter awards because of cost and time. Judging them on results for similar clients, references, team and value often reveals better-fitting options. Including at least one strong agency without awards in your comparison keeps the decision fair.
How do I recover from choosing the wrong agency?
Raise concerns clearly and give the agency a chance to fix them, referring to agreed goals. If problems continue, use your notice period, secure ownership of accounts and content and plan a careful handover. Learn from the selection process so the next choice is based on evidence.
Written by

Global Bridge Labs (GBL) is a UK–Sri Lanka partner for social media, websites and BPO. Everything here comes from client delivery, not theory.




