On this page
- 01Key takeaways
- 02How do you check an agency's results claims?
- 03What are common ways results are overstated?
- 04What evidence should an agency be able to show?
- 05When are results claims convincing?
- 06When should claims make you cautious?
- 07What does this look like in practice?
- 08Results claims checklist
- 09Next step
- 10Sources and further reading
- 11Frequently asked questions
Key takeaways
To check a social media agency's results claims, ask for the starting numbers, the timescale, the budget and ad spend and how results were measured and attributed. Claims such as tripled enquiries mean little without a baseline. Under the CAP Code, marketing claims must be supported by evidence, so reasonable questions should get clear answers.
- Ask for starting numbers and timescales.
- Ask about budget and ad spend.
- Ask how results were measured.
- Claims must be supported by evidence.
Want help checking an agency's results claims? Message us on WhatsApp.
Chat on WhatsApp →How do you check an agency's results claims?
Ask four questions: what was the starting point, over what period, with what budget and ad spend and how were results measured? Then ask whether other factors, such as price changes or seasonality, played a part. Specific, consistent answers suggest real results.
What are common ways results are overstated?
Common overstatements include percentages from tiny baselines, cherry-picked best months, counting all sales during a campaign as caused by it, reporting reach or engagement as success and leaving out ad spend. None need be dishonest, but they make results look bigger.
- Percentages from tiny baselines.
- Cherry-picked periods.
- Reach reported as results.
- Ad spend left out.
What evidence should an agency be able to show?
An agency should be able to show screenshots or exports from analytics, ad accounts or client systems, with client permission, plus a reference who can confirm the results. Effectiveness award entries and detailed case studies also count when they include baselines.
Want a second opinion on an agency's results evidence? Message us on WhatsApp and we will discuss your requirements.
Chat on WhatsApp →When are results claims convincing?
They are convincing when they include baselines, timescales and costs, come from similar clients and are confirmed by a reference or data you can see.
When should claims make you cautious?
Be cautious when claims are vague, use only percentages, cannot be supported with data or come with promises of guaranteed results for your business. A confident agency is usually happy to show the underlying numbers, so reluctance is itself useful information.
What does this look like in practice?
A pattern we see: an agency claims a 300% rise in leads; asked for the baseline, it was from three to twelve a month. Still useful, but very different from the impression the headline gives.
Results claims checklist
- Ask for the baseline.
- Ask for the timescale.
- Ask for budget and ad spend.
- Ask how results were measured.
- Confirm with a reference.
Next step
Pick the most impressive result an agency has shown you and ask the four questions about it.
Message us on WhatsApp for a claims review, or book a 30-minute consultation.
Chat on WhatsApp →Sources and further reading
- Substantiation: advice on backing up marketing claims · ASA and CAP
- UK Code of Non-broadcast Advertising and Direct & Promotional Marketing (CAP Code) · ASA / CAP
- Get started with attribution · Google Analytics Help
Frequently asked questions
Can a social media agency guarantee results?
Be cautious of guarantees. Results depend on your offer, prices, website, sales follow-up and market, not only the agency. Reputable agencies commit to activity, quality and agreed measures, and explain realistic expectations based on similar clients. Guaranteed results often come with conditions that make them less meaningful.
What is a good result from a social media agency?
A good result is a measurable improvement in the business goals you agreed, such as enquiries, bookings or sales, at a cost that pays back. It depends on your starting point, budget and timescale. Compare results with your own baseline rather than an agency's headline claims.
Are agency results claims regulated?
Agencies' own marketing claims must follow the CAP Code, which requires claims to be supported by evidence and not mislead. Consumer protection law also applies. In practice, the simplest protection is asking for baselines, timescales and evidence before relying on any results claim.
Written by

Global Bridge Labs (GBL) is a UK–Sri Lanka partner for social media, websites and BPO. Everything here comes from client delivery, not theory.




