On this page
- 01Key takeaways
- 02What do the different award tiers mean?
- 03Is a shortlisting worth anything to a buyer?
- 04Can an agency call itself award-winning after a shortlisting?
- 05When should a lower tier still impress you?
- 06When should tier wording make you cautious?
- 07What does this look like in practice?
- 08Award tier checklist
- 09Next step
- 10Sources and further reading
- 11Frequently asked questions
Key takeaways
A winner beat the other entries in its category. A shortlisted entry or finalist reached the last round. Highly commended sits between the two. All three are real achievements, but an agency describing a shortlisting as award-winning is overstating it, and under the CAP Code marketing claims must not mislead.
- Winner: top entry in its category that year.
- Finalist or shortlisted: reached the final round.
- Highly commended: praised, but did not win.
- Calling a shortlisting award-winning can mislead.
Unsure what an agency's award wording really means? Message us on WhatsApp.
Chat on WhatsApp →What do the different award tiers mean?
Award tiers show how far an entry got. A winner, sometimes with gold, silver or bronze levels, came top or near the top of its category. Finalists and shortlisted entries passed the first round of judging. Highly commended or special mentions recognise strong entries that did not win.
Is a shortlisting worth anything to a buyer?
Yes, a shortlisting shows the work impressed judges enough to reach the final round, which in competitive schemes is meaningful. Weigh it below a win and well below proven results for clients like you. What was judged still matters more than the tier reached.
- Competitive categories make shortlists meaningful.
- Small categories make shortlists easy.
- Results evidence matters more than the tier.
Can an agency call itself award-winning after a shortlisting?
It should not. Marketing claims must not mislead, and most buyers read award-winning as having won. The CAP Code requires claims to be accurate and supported by evidence, and unfair commercial practices rules also apply. Award-shortlisted or finalist is the honest wording.
Want help reading an agency's credentials page? Message us on WhatsApp and we will discuss your requirements.
Chat on WhatsApp →When should a lower tier still impress you?
A lower tier should impress you in a tough effectiveness category, or when the shortlisted work closely matches your sector and goals. A finalist place for exactly the kind of work you need can be worth more than a win in an unrelated category.
When should tier wording make you cautious?
Be cautious when an agency blurs tiers, lists shortlistings under a winners heading, or uses award-winning with no detail. Precise, modest wording usually signals an agency that will report results to you honestly too.
What does this look like in practice?
A pattern we see: a credentials deck lists twelve awards, of which two are wins and ten are shortlistings. Nothing is false, but asking for the list split by tier gives a fairer picture in seconds.
Award tier checklist
- Ask for awards split into wins and shortlistings.
- Note the category and year for each.
- Check the scheme's published results.
- Weigh relevance above tier.
- Note any blurred wording as a caution.
Next step
Ask each agency to send its awards as a simple list: tier, category, year, client. The answers sort themselves.
Message us on WhatsApp for a credentials review, or book a 30-minute consultation.
Chat on WhatsApp →Sources and further reading
- Substantiation: advice on backing up marketing claims · ASA and CAP
- UK Code of Non-broadcast Advertising and Direct & Promotional Marketing (CAP Code) · ASA / CAP
- Unfair commercial practices guidance (CMA207) · Competition and Markets Authority
Frequently asked questions
What does highly commended mean in an award?
Highly commended means the judges thought the entry was strong and worth recognising, but it did not win its category. It sits below a win and is usually given to a small number of entries. It is a fair achievement, but it should not be described as winning the award.
Is being a finalist the same as winning?
No. A finalist reached the last round of judging, which can be competitive, but did not win. Finalist or shortlisted is the accurate description. An agency that calls a finalist place a win is overstating its record, which is worth noting when you assess how it will report to you.
How do I check an agency's award tier?
Look up the award scheme's published winners and shortlists for the year claimed. Most schemes list them by category on their website. If the agency's claim does not appear, ask for the certificate or announcement. Honest agencies can show this quickly and without fuss.
Written by

Global Bridge Labs (GBL) is a UK–Sri Lanka partner for social media, websites and BPO. Everything here comes from client delivery, not theory.




